Jesse Kline: Carney doing nothing to stop businesses fleeing to escape Trump tariffs

Article content

As U.S. President Donald Trump’s Wednesday tariff deadline looms, there are worrying signs that Canadian manufacturers are going to pack up and move south of the border. This is unsurprising for a country that imposes high costs on businesses and seems to have resigned itself to being Trump’s whipping boy.

Article content

Last month, KPMG Canada released the results of a survey of 275 Canadian manufacturers conducted in May, which found that 42 per cent of them have considered, or are currently considering, moving production south of the border. Eleven per cent said they’re thinking of moving their head offices to the United States.

Article content

Article content

Article content

A few weeks later, the Financial Post reported that Vancouver-based Interfor Corp., one of the world’s largest lumber producers, plans to “shift its corporate and functional support operations” from British Columbia to Georgia, largely due to Trump’s crippling 45 per cent tariffs on softwood lumber.

Article content

Article content

Coercing manufacturers to relocate production to the U.S. is, of course, exactly what Trump hoped to achieve. It also explains why the president has singled Canada out for disproportionate punishment: while the U.S. can’t compete with developing countries on labour costs and moving operations from Europe is a costly endeavour, Canada is situated right next door, has an economy that’s already highly integrated with the U.S. and has relatively high wages and an uncompetitive tax system.

Article content

If these weren’t reasons enough to put Canada in the crosshairs, Prime Minister Mark Carney has shown little willingness to stand up to the bully next door. A year ago, he unilaterally removed most of the counter-tariffs imposed on American goods by his predecessor, only maintaining duties on steel, aluminum and automobiles to protect Canadian industry from similar U.S. tariffs.

Article content

Article content

It’s now apparent that this was a tactical mistake: Carney’s gesture of goodwill lost Canada a strategic bargaining chip, while failing to buy trade peace. Now, the Trump administration is citing Ottawa’s reciprocal tariffs on autos, along with booze bans imposed by some provinces in response to Trump’s trade war, as part of its justification for imposing 50 per cent tariffs on US$20 billion (C$28 billion) worth of Canadian goods.

Article content

Article content

Whether that actually happens remains to be seen: the president gets called on his bluffs so often, the acronym TACO (Trump always chickens out) has entered the English lexicon. Except once in a while, he kidnaps the president of Venezuela, bombs Iran or imposes tariffs on the entire world, ensuring everyone must remain on their toes at all times.

Article content

Regardless, the message to Canada, as explained by White House trade advisor Peter Navarro in these pages last month, is crystal clear: we will whip you as much as we want, and if you try to fight back, we’ll punish you even harder.

Article content

This position makes sense, given that most countries have quietly acquiesced to Trump’s tariffs. But Canada stands apart from the pack because we’re America’s second-largest trading partner, behind Mexico and ahead of China, and have had a free-trade agreement in place since 1989.